Advanced search
LIU Liang. Case Study on Multi-Disciplinary Controversy During the Development of Forestry in the Early Modern Times[J]. Journal of Beijing Forestry University (Social Science), 2020, 19(3): 67-78. DOI: 10.13931/j.cnki.bjfuss.2019185
Citation: LIU Liang. Case Study on Multi-Disciplinary Controversy During the Development of Forestry in the Early Modern Times[J]. Journal of Beijing Forestry University (Social Science), 2020, 19(3): 67-78. DOI: 10.13931/j.cnki.bjfuss.2019185
shu

Case Study on Multi-Disciplinary Controversy During the Development of Forestry in the Early Modern Times

  • Institute for the History of Natural Sciences, CAS, Beijing, 100190, P.R.China

More Information
  • Received Date: June 19, 2019
  • Available Online: August 18, 2020
  • Published Date: August 31, 2020
    Graphical Abstract
    • Abstract
  • In the course of the development of modern forestry, there have been many long-term controversy between forestry scientists and geographers, geologists, meteorologists, hydrologists, engineers and other groups. The paper analyzes five similar cases,which demonstrates the extensive exchanges and interactions between China and the United States in the field of forestry from the perspective of transnational scientific and technological communication.The relationship between forestry and geology, climatology, engineering and other fields is also analyzed from an interdisciplinary perspective.Finally, the paper sums up the characteristics of forestry research in early modern times.
    • FullText(HTML)
    • References (127)
  • [1]
    NISBET J. The climatic and national economic influence of forests [J]. Nature, 1894, 49（1265）: 302-305.
    [2]
    The floods of history [J]. Daily Alta California, 1889, 80（179）: 759.
    [3]
    王守春. 历史时期黄土高原植被变化与土壤侵蚀 [M]∥中国水利水电科学研究院水利史研究室. 历史的探索与研究−水利史研究文集.郑州: 黄河水利出版社, 2006: 169-197.
    [4]
    张镱锂,李炳元,郑度. 论青藏高原范围与面积[J]. 地理研究,2002,21(1):1-8. doi: 10.3321/j.issn:1000-0585.2002.01.001
    [5]
    侯甬坚. 专题视点:20世纪历史地理学思想源流考镜之一[J]. 云南大学学报(社会科学版),2017(3):49.
    [6]
    樊宝敏. 我国东南半壁优先实现森林化的战略构想[J]. 北京林业大学学报 (社会科学版),2019,18(3):1-6.
    [7]
    中国降雨临界点全线向北漂移[EB/OL].[2019-03-20]. https://weibo.com/ttarticle/p/show?id=2309404424480117096536.
    [8]
    付丽丽. 中国气候临界点出现大面积漂移? 专家: 危言耸听！[N]. 科技日报, 2019-10-12.
    [9]
    刘毅. 干涸湖泊漾碧波, 荒山秃岭披绿装: 西北缘何出现“暖湿化”趋势 [N]. 人民日报, 2019-11-13（15）.
    [10]
    气候变暖变湿, 西北如何应对: 既要合理利用, 又要科学防控 [N]. 人民日报, 2019-11-14（14）.
    [11]
    凌道扬. 森林与旱灾之关系[J]. 中国气象学会会刊,1925,1:47-58.
    [12]
    凌道扬. 水灾根本计划书[J]. 农商公报,1918,4(7):164-169.
    [13]
    凌道扬. 水灾根本救治方法[J]. 江苏省农会月报,1918,1(2):60-65.
    [14]
    李宜之. 北五省旱灾之主因及其根本救治之法[J]. 河海月刊,1921,4(1):1-6.
    [15]
    MALLORY W H. China: land of famine [M].Worcester: Commonwealth Press, 1926: 37, 141-162.
    [16]
    黄瑞采. 造林运动中三问题[J]. 文化月刊,1934,4:85-88.
    [17]
    QUICK H. American inland waterways [M]. New York: The Knickerbocker Press, 1909: 181-211, 228-234.
    [18]
    龚高法. 历史时期气候变化研究方法 [M]. 北京: 科学出版社, 1983: 3.
    [19]
    张丕远. 中国历史气候变化 [M]. 济南: 山东科学技术出版社, 1996: 前言.
    [20]
    大力推进生态文明建设 [N]. 经济日报, 2018-05-20（1）.
    [21]
    黄河流域生态保护和高质量发展是重大国家战略 [N]. 联合时报, 2019-09-20（1）.
    [22]
    加强生态保护治理 促进黄河流域高质量发展 [N]. 中国环境报, 2019-10-31（1）.
    [23]
    深入贯彻习近平总书记重要讲话精神 推动黄河流域生态保护和高质量发展 [N]. 河南日报, 2019-11-05（6）.
    [24]
    RICHTHOFEN F V. Report by Baron Von Richthofen of the provinces of Honan and Shansi [M] // Baron Richthofen’s Letters 1870-1872.Shanghai: North China Herald Office, 1872: 18-39.
    [25]
    HUNTINGTON E. The pulse of Asia [M]. New York: Houghton Mifflin Company, 1907: 208-209.
    [26]
    HUNTINGTON E, VISHER S. Climatic change, their nature and causes [M]. New Heaven: Yale University Press, 1922: 67.
    [27]
    STEIN A. Innermost Asia [M]. Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1928: 459-460.
    [28]
    SOWERBY A. Approaching desert conditions in North China[J]. China Journal of Science and Arts,1924,2(3):199-203.
    [29]
    SOWERBY A. Famine,afforestation and conservancy in China[J]. China Journal of Science and Arts,1929,11(6):303-306.
    [30]
    ENGLANDER A L. The origin and growth of deserts and the encroachment of the desert on North-China[J]. Journal of the North-China Branch of the Royal Asiatic Society,1928,30:204-226.
    [31]
    BUXTON L H. China, the land and the people, a human geography, with a chapter on the climate by W. G. Kendrew [M]. Oxford: The Clarendon Press, 1929: 71.
    [32]
    LIN D Y. Chapters on China and forestry [M]. Shanghai: Commercial Press, 1916: 59-70.
    [33]
    SHERFESEE W F. Some national aspects of forestry in China [N]. Millard’s Review of the Far East, 1921-04-09(294).
    [34]
    RUSSELL B. The problems of China [M]. New York: The Century Co., 1922: 3-14, 61-84.
    [35]
    早坂一郎. 砂漠化しつ〃ある支那[J]. 東洋學藝雜誌,1925,507:56-58.
    [36]
    蔡源明. 我国北方各省将化为沙漠之倾向与实证[J]. 东方杂志,1926,23(15):91-94.
    [37]
    张荫麟. 撰著提要:我国北方各省将化为沙漠之倾向与实证[J]. 清华学报,1926,3(2):287-357.
    [38]
    杜其垚. 中国北方森林的缺乏与沙漠状况的侵入[J]. 自然界,1926,8:692-696.
    [39]
    周建人. 沙漠的起源、长大及其侵入华北 [M] // 周建人.进化和退化.上海: 光华书局, 1930: 165-187.
    [40]
    鲁迅. 《进化与退化》小引[J]. 新文化,1945,2:34-35.
    [41]
    蒙文通. 中国古代北方气候考略[J]. 史学杂志,1930,2(3-4):7-8.
    [42]
    程伯群. 中国北方沙漠之扩张[J]. 科学,1934,18(6):784-794.
    [43]
    黄瑞采. 中国北部森林之摧残与气候变为沙漠状况之关系[J]. 江苏月报,1935,4:25-31.
    [44]
    毅人. 西北古今气候的变迁问题[M] //董兆祥. 西北开发史料选编（1930—1947）.北京: 经济科学出版社, 1998: 146-147.
    [45]
    邓叔群. 今日中国之森林问题[J]. 经济建设季刊,1942,1:218-222.
    [46]
    张国藩. 我国北部沙漠之南移问题[J]. 工程,1942,15(6):13-20.
    [47]
    李志水. 我国沙漠南移问题[J]. 西北公路管理局月刊,1945,7(3-4):50-52.
    [48]
    葛绥成. 中国北部各省亟宜植林以改造环境论 (上)[J]. 新中华,1947,5(22):40-45.
    [49]
    葛绥成. 中国北部各省亟宜植林以改造环境论 (下)[J]. 新中华,1947,5(23):36-40.
    [50]
    中国第二历史档案馆. 中华民国史料长编 （民国31年） [M]. 南京: 南京大学出版社, 1993: 940-941.
    [51]
    中国第二历史档案馆. 中华民国史料长编 （第67册） [M]. 南京: 南京大学出版社, 1993: 140-144.
    [52]
    LOWDERMILK W C. Man-made deserts[J]. Pacific Affairs,1935,8(4):409-419. doi: 10.2307/2751240
    [53]
    CHU C C. Climatic pulsations during historic time in China[J]. Geographical Review,1924,16(2):274-282.
    [54]
    TING V K. Notes on the records of droughts and floods in Shensi and the supposed desiccation of N. W. China[J]. Geografiska Annaler,1935,14:453-462.
    [55]
    MOYER R T. The aridity of North China[J]. Journal of the North-China Branch of the Royal Asiatic Society,1932,33:65-80.
    [56]
    ROOSEVELT T. Message of the president of the United States communicated to the two houses of congress at the beginning of the Second Session of the Sixtieth Congress [M].Washington: Government Printing Office, 1908: 22-28, Illustrations No.1-10.
    [57]
    Final report of the National Waterways Commission, 62D Congress 2d Session [M]. Washington: Government Printing Office, 1912: 28-36.
    [58]
    WEEKS J W, LEVER A F. Acquiring land for the protection of watersheds for the conservation of navigable streams, 60th Congress 2d Session, House of Representatives [M]. Washington: Government Printing Office, 1909: 1-10.
    [59]
    Report of the national conservation commission （February 1909） Volume 1 [M]. Washington: Government Printing Office, 1909.
    [60]
    Report of the national conservation commission with accompanying papers （February 1909） Volume 2 [M]. Washington: Government Printing Office, 1909.
    [61]
    Report of the national conservation commission with accompanying papers （February 1909） Volume 3 [M]. Washington: Government Printing Office, 1909.
    [62]
    Annual report of the chief of Engineers United State Army, 1910 [M]. Washington: Government Printing Office, 1910.
    [63]
    ZON R. Forests and water in the light of scientific investigation[M]//Final Report of the National Waterways Commission. Washington: Government Printing Office, 1912: 207.
    [64]
    CHITTENDEN H M. Forests and reservoirs in their relation to stream flow, with particular reference to navigable rivers [J].Transactions of the American Society of Civil Engineers, 1909, 62:245-546.
    [65]
    SWAIN G F. The equalizing influence of forests on the flow of streams and their value as a means of improving navigation (1)[J]. Conservation,1909,15(8):488-494.
    [66]
    SWAIN G F. The equalizing influence of forests on the flow of streams and their value as a means of improving navigation (2)[J]. Conservation,1909,15(9):557-562.
    [67]
    HARTS W W. Natural waterways in the United States: review of recent progress and present tendencies [M] // Waterways and irrigation. San Francisco: Press of the Neal Publishing Company, 1916: 58-109.
    [68]
    CHITTENDEN H M. Flood control: with particular reference to conditions in the United States [M] // Waterways and irrigation. San Francisco: Press of the Neal Publishing Company, 1916: 110-253.
    [69]
    JAMESON C D. Flood control in China [M] //Waterways and irrigation. San Francisco: Press of the Neal Publishing Company, 1916: 254-278.
    [70]
    CHITTENDEN H M. The myth of the forests [N]. The New York Times, 1916-06-17（10）.
    [71]
    GAMEWELL M N. New life currents in China [M]. New York: Missionary Education Movement of the United States and Canada, 1919: 110.
    [72]
    Permanent China relief [N]. The New York Times, 1921-05-01（91）.
    [73]
    凌道扬. 为本岁各省水灾事敬告国人急宜造林以为根本救济[J]. 实业杂志,1924,5(1):1-16.
    [74]
    LOWDERMILK W C. A plan for the conservation of water resources [N]. The China Weekly Review, 1925-11-14（257）.
    [75]
    MALLORY W H.The question of feeding China’s millions [N]. The China Weekly Review, 1926-12-11（32）.
    [76]
    LIN D Y. The question of forests and floods [N]. The China Weekly Review, 1927-01-08（147）.
    [77]
    HELMS J D. Walter Lowdermilk’s journey:forester to land conservationist[J]. Environmental Review,1984,8(2):132-145.
    [78]
    凌道扬. 中国农业之经济观 [M]. 上海: 商务印书馆, 1926: 78.
    [79]
    凌道扬. 造林与民生[J]. 国立中央大学农学院旬刊,1930,49:1-3.
    [80]
    凌道扬. 建设全国森林意见书[J]. 建设,1930,9:44-52.
    [81]
    凌道扬. 由旱灾说到造林[J]. 江苏月报,1935,3(4):54-57.
    [82]
    Afforestation the only remedy for China’s recurrent floods [N]. The North China Herald, 1924-08-30（334）.
    [83]
    This may be called Chinese pinchotism [J]. Los Angeles Herald, 1916, 42（49）: 12.
    [84]
    LOWDERMILK W C. The boxer money and China’s water supply [N]. The North China Herald, 1926-07-24（170）.
    [85]
    BAKER J E. China’s recurrent famine: two causes are held responsible for the suffering [N]. The New York Times, 1928-05-27（128）.
    [86]
    STROBE G G. The general problem of relief from floods [N]. The China Weekly Review, 1931-10-31（337）.
    [87]
    DU HALDE J B. A description of the empire of China and Chinese-Tartary （two volumes） [M]. London: Edward Cave, 1741: 296.
    [88]
    FORTUNE R. Three years’ wandering in the northern provinces of China [M]. London: John Murray, 1847: 3.
    [89]
    PRATT A E. To the snows of Tibet through China [M]. London: Longmans, Green, and Co., 1892: 27.
    [90]
    DAVID A. Journal de Mon Troisième Voyage d’exploration dans I’Empire Chinois [M]. Paris: Librairie Hachette et Cie, 1875: 72, 184, 187, 280, 345.
    [91]
    HUC M. Travels in Tartary, Thibet and China during the years 1844-5-6（vol.1） [M]. Chicago: The Open Court Publishing Company, 1900: 4-5.
    [92]
    MEYER F N. Photograph album of the first plant expedition in China of Frank N. Meyer [M]. Washington: Office of Foreign Seed and Plant Introduction, 1908: 63, 89, 93, 95, 121, 123.
    [93]
    ARCHIVE III W P. William Purdom （1880-1921） papers, 1909-1912 guide [M]. Cambridge: Harvard University, 2011.
    [94]
    WILSON E H. The kingdom of flowers:an account of the wealth of trees and shrubs of China and of what the Arnold Arboretum with China’s help is doing to enrich America[J]. The National Geographic Magazine,1911,22(10):1003-1035.
    [95]
    WILLIS B. Deforestation in China[J]. Proceedings of the Society of American Foresters,1906,1(3):141-146.
    [96]
    CLEVELAND T JR. What forestry has done [M]. Washington: Government Printing Office, 1908.
    [97]
    SHERFESEE W F. Some national aspects of forestry in China [N]. Millard’s Review of the Far East, 1921-04-09（294）.
    [98]
    HILLER W C. The famine in North China [N]. The North China Herald, 1879-04-15（361）.
    [99]
    NORDEN W M. Who’ who of the Chinese in New York [M]. New York: Cornell University Library, 1918: 100-102.
    [100]
    TEICHMAN E. Travels of a consular officer in North-West China [M]. Cambridge: The Cambridge University Press, 1921: 30, 111.
    [101]
    LIN D Y. Forests and chihli floods [M]. Nanking: University of Nanking, 1918: 1-13.
    [102]
    LOWDERMILK W C,CHALL M. Forests and erosion in China,1922-1927[J]. Forestry History,1972,16(1):4-15.
    [103]
    TODD O J. Practical education and famine relief in China [N]. The China Weekly Review, 1924-07-26（267）.
    [104]
    TODD O J. Chief engineer describes role of famine relief commission [N]. The China Press, 1934-10-01（9）.
    [105]
    LOWDERMILK W C. Erosion and floods in the Yellow River watershed[J]. Journal of Forestry,1924,22(6):11-18.
    [106]
    LOWDERMILK W C. Forest destruction and slope denudation in the Province of Shansi[J]. The China Journal of Science and Arts,1926,4(3):127-135.
    [107]
    LOWDERMILK W C,SMITH J R. Notes on the problem of field erosion[J]. Geographical Review,1927,17(2):226-235. doi: 10.2307/208225
    [108]
    罗德民. 行政院顾问罗德民考察西北水土保持初步报告[J]. 水利月刊,1944,1(4):36-48.
    [109]
    FEDOTOVA A A, LOSKUTOVA M V. Forests, climate and the rise of scientific forestry in Russia: from local knowledge and natural history to modern experiments （1840s-early1890s）[M] // DENISE P, SHARON K. New perspectives on the history of life sciences and agriculture, archimedes Vol.40.Bern: Springer International Publishing Switzerland, 2015: 113-137.
    [110]
    ZON R. Forests and water in the light of scientific investigation [M]. Washington: Government Printing Office, 1927: 3.
    [111]
    COEN D R. Climate in motion: science, empire and the problems of scale [M]. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 2018: 240-241.
    [112]
    China cites deforestation as a cause of floods [N]. The New York Times, 1998-08-23（11）.
    [113]
    ECKHOLM E. China admits ecological sins played role in flood disaster [N]. The New York Times, 1998-08-26（A1）.
    [114]
    WANG C D. Nationwide forest protection measure to help prevent repetition of summer flood catastrophe [N]. China Daily, 1998-09-06（1）.
    [115]
    ECKHOLM E. Stunned by floods, China hastens logging curbs [N]. The New York Times, 1998-09-27（3）.
    [116]
    The floods: natural disaster compounds human error in mainland Chinese flood disasters [N]. Inside China Mainland, 1998-10-01（1）.
    [117]
    China: flood impact [N]. Oxford Analytica Daily Brief Service, 1998-10-08（1）.
    [118]
    POMFRET J. Yangtze flood jolts China’s land policies [N]. The Washington Post, 1998-11-22（A31）.
    [119]
    谈英武,杨维九. 2010年西南大旱的启示[J]. 南水北调与水利科技,2011,9(1):16-19.
    [120]
    孙英兰. 科学家把脉西南大旱[J]. 瞭望,2010(13):11-12.
    [121]
    孟凡贵. 难以忽视的真相−耕作制度变迁与中国北方干旱[J]. 城市中国,2009(37):28-33.
    [122]
    KHAN S. Suicide by drought: how China is destroying its own water supply [N]. Foreign Affairs, 2014-07-18.
    [123]
    HANER J. Living in China’s expanding deserts [N]. The New York Times, 2016-10-24（A8）.
    [124]
    内蒙古自治区环境保护宣传教育中心. 生态文明建设和环境保护重要文件汇编 [M]. 北京: 中国环境出版社, 2017: 4-17.
    [125]
    范盛泰. 生态文明建设生动范例塞罕坝: 荒原变林海 精神永传承 [C]//对接京津−经济强省 绿色发展论文集.廊坊: 河北省廊坊市应用经济学会, 2018: 65-69.
    [126]
    HODGKIN H T. Living issues in China [M]. New York: Friendship Press, 1932: 21, 96.
    [127]
    任承统. 建设西北与水土保持 [M] // 唐润明. 抗战时期大后方经济开发文献资料选编.重庆: 重庆出版社, 2005: 470-472.
    • Related Articles

Catalog

    Get Citation
    PDF
    XML
    Article views (1020) PDF downloads (38) Cited by()
    Turn off MathJax
    Article Contents
    Abstract
    References

    Copyright © 2013 Editorial Department of Beijing Forestry University 京ICP备05066833号-1

    Address：North-Star Times Tower, No.8 Beichendong Road, Chaoyang District, Beijing, China. China Pos：100083

    Tel：010-62337919 Fax：021-64253812

    Supported by: Beijing Renhe Information Technology Co., Ltd.  Baidu Analytics

    /

    DownLoad:  Full-Size Img  PowerPoint
    Return
    Return